Is there any difference in the voltage (potential difference wrt center) and current (rate of flow of electrons) distribution for a half wave dipole fed in the middle (dipole cut in the middle,) or fed with a gamma match (dipole one piece) ?

At the highest level, no. Current is still highest in the middle, and voltage highest at the ends. The radiation pattern is practically identical.

Looking more closely, there must be differences, otherwise it would be indistinguishable from a center-fed dipole. Part of the gamma match can be viewed as a shorted transmission line in parallel with the feedpoint. The currents on this transmission line can then be considered the superposition of the common mode and the differential mode. The common mode radiates as a dipole would. The differential mode does not.

See also What is a Gamma match in the context of the driven element of a Yagi antenna?

  • Hi again Phil. For a half wave dipole, the current at the ends is zero because it's an open circuit and the current has nowhere to go right ? Then for a half wave dipole that is cut in the center and has it's feed point between the two inner center ends, how can the current be at a maximum in the middle ? I don't get it. – Andrew Nov 6 at 21:51
  • 1
    The dipole may be cut, but it's not an open circuit. For every electron that enters one conductor of the feedline, another electron exits the other conductor. So in fact the feedpoint doesn't impede current at all. – Phil Frost - W8II Nov 7 at 0:20
  • Hi Phil, Thank you. – Andrew Nov 7 at 1:38

The voltage at the feedpoint of a center-fed 50 ohm dipole driven by 100 watts is 70.7 volts RMS. If you gamma feed that same dipole, the voltage at the center is zero. At that center point in a gamma fed dipole, all of the RF energy is in the magnetic field and zero in the electric field. At the tips of the dipole where the current is necessarily zero, all of the RF energy is in the electric field.

Note that the feedpoint of a center-fed dipole is not a point - it is two points with a space (insulator) in between the two points. Ideally, at the point at the center of the insulator, the electric field is zero just as it is with a gamma feed. Since the voltage is proportional to the electric field, the voltage would also be zero as it is with a gamma feed. If the dipole is fed with coax and no balun at the feedpoint, this ideal situation probably will not exist.

To answer the question: There is negligible difference in the radiation patterns between a properly center-fed dipole and a properly gamma-fed dipole.

New contributor
w5dxp is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering. Check out our Code of Conduct.
  • As the electromagnetic fields exist in all the space around the antenna, how does it make sense to say all the energy is in one field or another at a particular point? The energy is in the field itself, like a stretched spring. It doesn't exist at any particular point. – Phil Frost - W8II 16 hours ago

Your Answer

 

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.