Take the 2-minute tour ×
Amateur Radio Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for amateur radio enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

A loopstick antenna, if you don't know, is a coil of many turns around a high permeability core. They are frequently encountered in AM receivers and look like this:

loopstick antenna photo

This particular example is actually two antennas on one core.

What type of material is an appropriate core for these antennas? What material parameters are relevant in the selection of an appropriate core, and how do they affect antenna performance?

share|improve this question

1 Answer 1

up vote 2 down vote accepted

As it's name implies, a loopstick antenna is a magnetic loop antenna and is one of the best choices for an electrically short antenna; necessary because broadcast AM wavelengths are hundreds of meters long.

Rather than a regular loop, a loopstick utilizes a large amount of (usually Litz) wire wrapped around a ferrite rod. This forms an inductor which is tuned to resonance by a variable capacitor as the radio is tuned to a frequency.

The material for the core of these antennas is ferrite -- a powdered iron based magnetic material with a variety of other metals added. The exact composition of the ferrite material (called it's "mix") governs it's characteristics.

The goal of the ferrite is to produce a very high Q inductor with a high electrical resistance. The efficiency of the inductor is governed by the permeability of the ferrite core and the core's permeability changes with frequency.

This is because the ferrite itself absorbs power. This arises from the energy required to change the magnetic alignment of the magnetic domains inside the granular structure of the ferrite. The higher the frequency, the greater the number of changes and hence the higher the loss, generally dropping off sharply. See the following chart (lifted from the Fair-Rite catalog) for example:

Fair-Rite Mix 61 Perm

In the chart, μ' is the permeability of the ferrite and μ" is the ferrite induced losses. While the permeability continues to rise until about 11 MHz, the loses begin to rise dramatically starting at about 4.5MHz. This is why Fair-Rite Corp only recommends this mix through about 5MHz.

This is a chart of their "mix 61", which uses Nickel and Zinc in the iron to achieve it's characteristics and is recommended as the proper one for AM broadcast frequency antenna material.

For HF frequencies, they recommend "mix 73", a combination of Nickel and Manganese which performs well up to about 50MHz as shown here:

Fair-Rite Mix 73

It's worth noting in this chart that the losses are much higher than the MF band material, but so is the permeability.

This is probably a good time to underline an important characteristic of ferrite: while it concentrates the magnetic fields, it has a very high electrical resistance. This isn't very important for receiving. But the use of ferrite in a transmitting antenna, or as is more common among hams, as a transformer in baluns or ununs, it can be important.

Ferrite's resistance is inversely related to it's permeability. The less permeable ferrite becomes, the more resistant it becomes. Ferrite's permeability is also affected by temperature. As the ferrite warms up, it's permeability increases until it reaches what's called it's Curie temperature, for this mix, about 160° C. At that point ferrite rapidly loses it's permeability as shown in this graph:

Mix 73 curie temp graph

And this is how baluns and ununs fail. Power through the transformer warms the material due to the ferrite related loses. All is OK until the curie temperature it reached and then the permeability falls off a cliff and the resistance increases causing more heating in a runaway thermal loop until your coax melts and shorts the inner conductor to the shield.

share|improve this answer
    
Can you elaborate on what that graph means? What if I wanted to make a loopstick antenna for the amateur HF bands? What would I look for in the datasheets? –  Phil Frost Dec 25 '13 at 14:07
    
@Phil, I have expanded the discussion on the datasheets, have a look. –  WPrecht - AB3RY Dec 25 '13 at 17:52
    
Why would the ferrite's electrical resistance matter? Are there significant electrical currents in the ferrite? –  Phil Frost Dec 25 '13 at 18:19
    
It's largely magnetic, but not completely. The electrical resistance is high though. This isn't a problem unless the current through the ferrite causes heating and approached the Curie temp as noted. –  WPrecht - AB3RY Dec 25 '13 at 23:45

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.